十二指肠乳头括约肌切开后球囊扩张术和乳头括约肌切开术治疗巨大胆总管结石效果比较的Meta分析

任效瑛; 吴永彪; 丁相元; 李雪; 闫慧明

doi:10.3969/j.issn.1001-5256.2020.04.028

十二指肠乳头括约肌切开后球囊扩张术和乳头括约肌切开术治疗巨大胆总管结石效果比较的Meta分析

DOI: 10.3969/j.issn.1001-5256.2020.04.028

1. 山西医科大学第二临床医学院
2. 贵州省兴义市人民医院普外科
3. 山西医科大学第二医院普外科

详细信息

中图分类号: R657.42
计量
- 文章访问数: 1069
- HTML全文浏览量: 33
- PDF下载量: 211
- 被引次数: 0
出版历程
- 收稿日期: 2019-10-31
- 出版日期: 2020-04-20

Clinical effect of endoscopic sphincterotomy with balloon dilation versus sphincterotomy alone in treatment of large common bile duct stones: A Meta-analysis

The Second College of Clinical Medcine,Shanxi Medical University

摘要

摘要: 目的评价两种手术方式十二指肠乳头括约肌切开术（EST）和十二指肠乳头括约肌切开后球囊扩张术（ESBD）处理巨大胆总管结石的疗效差异。方法计算机检索至2019年7月8日的Pubmed、Cochrane Central、Embase等外文数据库及中国知网、万方等中文数据库中的文献,同时检索相关会议论文等,纳入ESBD vs EST治疗巨大胆总管结石的随机对照试验（RCT）,提取相关数据,采用RevMan5. 3软件进行分析。结果共纳入13项RCT,共计1926例患者,其中ESBD组973例,EST组953例。Meta分析结果显示:ESBD组和EST组结石清除率[比值比（OR）=1. 53,95%可信区间（95%CI）:1. 03～2. 29,P=0. 04]、一次清除率（OR=1. 77,95%CI:1. 06～2. 93,P=0. 03）、机械碎石率（OR=0. 40,95%CI:0. 25～0. 63,P <0. 000 1）、出血率（OR=0. 23,95%CI:0. 11～0. 50,P <0. 001）、胆管炎发生率（OR=0. 31,95%CI:0. 12～0. 7...
- 胆总管结石 /
- 气囊扩张术 /
- 括约肌切开术,内窥镜 /
- Meta分析(主题)
Abstract: Objective To investigate the clinical effect of endoscopic sphincterotomy with balloon dilation( ESBD) versus sphincterotomy( EST) alone in the treatment of large common bile duct stones. Methods Foreign databases( including PubMed,Cochrane Central,and Embase) and Chinese databases( including CNKI and Wanfang Data) were searched for randomized controlled trials( RCTs) on the clinical effect of ESBD versus EST in the treatment of large common bile duct stones published up to July 8,2019. Related data were extracted and RevMan5. 3 was used for analysis. Results A total of 13 RCTs with 1926 patients were included,with 973 patients in the ESBD group and953 patients in the EST group. The meta-analysis showed that there were significant differences between the ESBD group and the EST group in stone clearance rate( odds ratio [OR]= 1. 53,95% confidence interval [CI]: 1. 03-2. 29,P = 0. 04),one-time clearance rate( OR= 1. 77,95% CI: 1. 06-2. 93,P = 0. 03),rate of use of mechanical lithotripsy( OR = 0. 40,95% CI: 0. 25-0. 63,P < 0. 000 1),bleeding rate( OR = 0. 23,95% CI: 0. 11-0. 50,P < 0. 001),incidence rate of cholangitis( OR = 0. 31,95% CI: 0. 12-0. 78,P = 0. 01),incidence rate of early complications( OR = 0. 59,95% CI: 0. 42-0. 84,P = 0. 003),and time of operation( mean difference =-8. 89,95% CI:-17. 56 to-0. 22,P = 0. 04),while there were no significant differences between the two groups in perforation( OR = 0. 27,95% CI: 0. 05-1. 30,P = 0. 10) and pancreatitis after endoscopy( OR = 1. 03,95% CI: 0. 66-1. 61,P = 0. 91). Conclusion In endoscopic treatment of large common bile duct stones,ESBD has several advantages over EST in stone clearance rate,rate of use of mechanical lithotripsy,bleeding rate,incidence rate of cholangitis,and time of operation.
- choledocholithiasis /
- balloon valvuloplasty /
- sphincterotomy,endoscopic /
- Meta-analysis as topic

HTML全文

参考文献(34)

[1] SIEGEL JH,KASMIN FE. Biliary tract diseases in the elderly:management and outcomes[J]. Gut,1997,41(4):433-435.

[2] HACKER KA,SCHULTZ CC,HELLING TS. Choledochotomy for calculous disease in the elderly[J]. Am J Surg,1990,160(6):610-612; discussion 613.

[3] TESTONI PA,MARIANI A,AABAKKEN L,et al. Papillary cannulation and sphincterotomy techniques at ERCP:European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy(ESGE)clinical guideline[J]. Endoscopy,2016,48(7):657-683.

[4] DUMONCEAU JM,ANDRIULLI A,ELMUNZER BJ,et al. Prophylaxis of post-ERCP pancreatitis:European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy(ESGE)guideline-updated June 2014[J].Endoscopy,2014,46(9):799-815.

[5] CARR-LOCKE DL. Difficult bile-duct stones:Cut,dilate,or both?[J]. Gastrointest Endosc,2008,67(7):1053-1055.

[6] ERSOZ G,TEKESIN O,OZUTEMIZ AO,et al. Biliary sphincterotomy plus dilation with a large balloon for bile duct stones that are difficult to extract[J]. Gastrointest Endosc,2003,57(2):156-159.

[7] JUN BQ,LI HX,TIAN MC,et al. Small endoscopic sphincterotomy plus large-balloon dilation for removal of large common bile duct stones during ERCP[J]. Pak J Med Sci,2013,2 9(4):907-912.

[8] YANG XM,HU B. Endoscopic sphincterotomy plus largeballoon dilation vs endoscopic sphincterotomy for choledocholithiasis:A meta-analysis.[J]. World J Gastroenterol,2013,19(48):9453-9460.

[9] WANG ZC,LIN YG,WEN BS. Application of endoscpic duodenal sphincterotomy and endoscopic papillary balloon dilatation in treatment of patients with cholelithiasis[J]. J Prac Hepatol,2018,21(6):977-978.(in Chinese)王昭灿，林尤冠，温必盛．乳头括约肌小切开联合内镜下乳头球囊扩张术治疗胆总管结石患者疗效对比分析[J]．实用肝脏病杂志，2018,21(6):977-978.

[10] TAO T,ZHANG M,ZHANG QJ,et al. Efficiency and safety of limited endoscopic sphincterotomy plus endoscopic papillary balloon dilation in the treatment of giant choledocholithiasis[J]. Chin J Clin Res,2018,31(9):1185-1189.(in Chinese)陶涛，张明，张启杰，等．内镜下乳头括约肌小切开后球囊扩张治疗巨大胆总管结石[J]．中国临床研究，2018,31(9):1185-1189.

[11] KARSENTI D,CORON E,VANBIERVLIET G,et al. Complete endoscopic sphincterotomy with vs. without large-balloon dilation for the removal of large bile duct stones:Randomized multicenter study[J]. Endoscopy,2017,49(10):968-976.

[12] CUI ZQ,ZHAO WD,GUO Z,et al. Clinical study of small endoscopic sphincterotomy combined with endoscopic balloon dilatationfor large common bile duct stones[J]. Chin J Mod Med,2016,26(16):118-123.(in Chinese)崔振芹，赵卫东，郭壮，等．乳头括约肌小切开联合柱状球囊扩张术治疗巨大型胆总管结石的临床研究[J]．中国现代医学杂志，2016,26(16):118-123.

[13] GUO Y,LEI S,GONG W,et al. A preliminary comparison of endoscopic sphincterotomy,endoscopic papillary large balloon dilation,and combination of the two in endoscopic choledocholithiasis treatment[J]. Med Sci Monit,2015,21:2607-2612.

[14] MU H,GAO J,KONG Q,et al. Prognostic factors and postoperative recurrence of calculus following small-incision sphincterotomy with papillary balloon dilation for the treatment of intractable choledocholithiasis:A 72-month follow-up study[J]. Dig Dis Sci,2015,60(7):2144-2149.

[15] LI G,PANG Q,ZHANG X,et al. Dilation-assisted stone extraction:An alternative method for removal of common bile duct stones[J]. Dig Dis Sci,2014,59(4):857-864.

[16] TEOH AY,CHEUNG FK,HU B,et al. Randomized trial of endoscopic sphincterotomy with balloon dilation versus endoscopic sphincterotomy alone for removal of bile duct stones[J]. Gastroenterology,2013,144(2):341-345.

[17] STEFANIDIS G,VIAZIS N,PLESKOW D,et al. Large balloon dilation vs. mechanical lithotripsy for the management of large bile duct stones:A prospective randomized study[J]. Am J Gastroenterol,2011,106(2):278-285.

[18] LIU ZJ,GUO JT,WANG S,et al. Comparison of endoscopic sphincterotomy plus large-balloon dilation and endoscopic sphincterotomy for removal of bileduct stones[J]. China J Endosc,2011,17(9):924-928.(in Chinese)刘治军，郭瑾陶，王晟，等．内镜下乳头括约肌切开加大球囊扩张与常规乳头括约肌切开治疗胆总管结石的比较研究[J]．中国内镜杂志，2011,17(9):924-928.

[19] KIM HG,CHEON YK,CHO YD,et al. Small sphincterotomy combined with endoscopic papillary large balloon dilation versus sphincterotomy[J]. World J Gastroenterol,2009,15(34):4298-4304.

[20] HEO JH,KANG DH,JUNG HJ,et al. Endoscopic sphincterotomy plus large-balloon dilation versus endoscopic sphincterotomy for removal of bile-duct stones[J]. Gastrointest Endosc,2007,66(4):720-726; quiz 768,771.

[21] PARK CH,JUNG JH,NAM E,et al. Comparative efficacy of various endoscopic techniques for the treatment of common bile duct stones:A network meta-analysis[J]. Gastrointest Endosc,2018,87(1):43-57.

[22] DONG SQ,SINGH TP,ZHAO Q,et al. Sphincterotomy plus balloon dilation versus sphincterotomy alone for choledocholithiasis:A meta-analysis[J]. Endoscopy,2019,51(8):763-771.

[23] XU L,KYAW MH,TSE YK,et al. Endoscopic sphincterotomy with large balloon dilation versus endoscopic sphincterotomy for bile duct stones:A systematic review and meta-analysis[J]. Biomed Res Int,2015,2015:673103.

[24] JUNIOR CC,BERNARDO WM,FRANZINI TP,et al. Comparison between endoscopic sphincterotomy vs endoscopic sphincterotomy associated with balloon dilation for removal of bile duct stones:A systematic review and meta-analysis based on randomized controlled trials[J]. World J Gastrointest Endosc,2018,10(8):130-144.

[25] HE YF,TANG SH,GUO WW,et al. Efficacy and safety of minor endoscopic sphincterotomy combined with endoscopic papillary large balloon dilation in treatment of elderly patients with multiple large common bile duct stones[J]. J Clin Hepatol,2018,34(2):341-345.(in Chinese)贺永锋，汤善宏，郭文伟，等．内镜下乳头括约肌小切开联合大球囊扩张治疗老年胆总管多发巨大结石的效果及安全性分析[J]．临床肝胆病杂志，2018,34(2):3 41-345.

[26] WEINBERG BM,SHINDY W,LO S. Endoscopic balloon sphincter dilation(sphincteroplasty)versus sphincterotomy for common bile duct stones[J]. Cochrane Database Syst Rev,2006,(4):CD004890.

[27] KUO CM,CHIU YC,LIANG CM,et al. Limited precut sphincterotomy combined with endoscopic papillary balloon dilation for common bile duct stone removal in patients with difficult biliary cannulation[J]. BMC Gastroenterol,2016,16(1):70.

[28] TSAI MC,WANG CC,WANG YT,et al. Major bleeding risk of endoscopic sphincterotomy versus endoscopic papillary balloon dilatation in hemodialysis patients[J]. Saudi J Gastroenterol,2019,25(2):106-112.

[29] ITOI T,RYOZAWA S,KATANUMA A,et al. Japan Gastroenterological Endoscopy Society guidelines for endoscopic papillary large balloon dilation[J]. Dig Endosc,2018,30(3):293-309.

[30] PARK SJ,KIM JH,HWANG JC,et al. Factors predictive of adverse events following endoscopic papillary large balloon dilation:Results from a multicenter series[J]. Dig Dis Sci,2013,58(4):1100-1109.

[31] PASPATIS GA,PARASKEVA K. Author reply:Comment to“Sixty versus thirty seconds papillary balloon dilation after sphincterotomy for the treatment of large bile duct stones:A randomized controlled trial”[J]. Dig Liver Dis,2013,45(8):700-701.

[32] ZHOU L,WANG JX,PENG DS. Clinical effect of endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography cambined with endoscopic sphincterotomy of papilla in treatment of billiary tralt disease[J]. China Med Herald,2019,35(16):127-130.(in Chinese)周岚，王建祥，彭东曙．经内镜逆行性胰胆管造影术联合内镜乳头括约肌切开术治疗胆道疾病的临床效果[J]．中国医药导报，2019,36(16):127-130.

[33] MANES G,PASRATIS G,AABAKKEN L,et al. Endoscopic management of common bile duct stones:European Society of Gastrointestinal Endoscopy(ESGE)guideline[J]. Endoscopy,2019,51(5):472-491.

[34] ERCP group,Chinese Society of Digestive Endoscopology;Biliopancreatic group,Chinese Association of Gastroenterologist and hepatologist,National Clinical Research Center for Digestive Diseases. Chinese Guidelines for ERCP(2018)[J]. J Clin Hepatol,2018,34(12):2537-2554.(in Chinese)中华医学会消化内镜学分会ERCP学组，中国医师协会消化医师分会胆胰学组，国家消化系统疾病临床医学研究中心．中国经内镜逆行胰胆管造影术指南(2018版)[J]．临床肝胆病杂志，2018,34(12):2537-2554.

施引文献

资源附件(0)

访问统计